Skip to guide content
Things I Actually UseIndependent product guide
All recommendations

renae gr's pick · Updated June 2026

Temptations Cat Treats Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats

Temptations Cat Treats Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, Savory Salmon Flavor, 48 oz. Bag
The pick

I keep a bag like this around because cats do not let you get away with being inconsistent. If you have a cat that comes running the second it hears a treat bag, or a picky one that needs a little convincing to come out from under the couch, this is the kind of thing that earns its place in the pantry fast. The mix of crunchy and soft treats makes it easier to use for different moods, which matters more than people think when the little animal in your house has opinions about texture.

What I like most is that these are easy to hand out without turning snack time into a mess. The pieces are small enough to use as a reward during play, but they still feel like an actual treat instead of tiny crumbs. That is a better balance than a lot of cat snacks that are either too hard or so soft they fall apart in the bag. The salmon flavor is strong enough that most cats will notice it right away, and that is really the job here. You want something that gets attention quickly and does not leave you standing there shaking the bag like a fool.

I also like the big bag format for a normal household. If you use treats every day, the larger size makes sense because you are not constantly replacing a little container that disappears too fast. It is the sort of thing I would buy for someone who trains their cat with treats, uses them to get a nervous cat out of hiding, or just likes having a simple reward ready for good behavior. Even just calling a cat out for dinner or getting them to come in from the porch goes smoother when the treat bag has some pull to it.

The one downside is that the bag is a little awkward to store once it has been opened. It is not a huge problem, but it is the kind of bulky package that takes more pantry space than you want it to. I usually clip it shut and tuck it somewhere dry, but a reseal that felt a little more secure would make it easier to live with. Small thing, but you notice it if you keep treats on hand all the time.

I use treats like this for the boring parts of cat life too, not just for being cute. It is easier to get a cat moving, easier to redirect them, and easier to make yourself look like the favorite person in the room when you have something they actually want. That is probably the real reason this kind of treat ends up in so many carts. It is not fancy. It just does the job.

If your cat likes salmon and you want a treat that can handle both crunchy and soft preferences in one bag, this is an easy one to keep around. I would recommend it to anyone who wants a simple everyday treat that feels useful instead of random. It is the kind of thing that quietly disappears into the routine, which is usually how you know it was worth buying in the first place.

Amazon product links on this guide are not currently affiliate links. Neither renae gr nor Buyer Field Guide earns an affiliate commission from them.

See current price